Why 'One and Done' Recruiting Hinders Staffing Agency Success
The term one-and-done is often associated with athletes, typically basketball players, who spend just one year in college before going professional. In recruiting, however, practices like this have a name too—‘one-and-done.’ Agencies that fail to track and improve recruiter performance metrics often find themselves struggling to deliver results and grow financially.
When staffing agencies rely on minimal effort to fill job openings, they risk damaging their reputation among clients and candidates alike. In a competitive labor market, delivering high-quality candidates consistently is essential to building trust and repeat business.
What is 'One and Done' Recruiting?
One-and-done recruiting is defined by minimal effort in candidate submissions. This approach includes:
- Submitting only one candidate for an open job.
- Making one poor attempt at sourcing or producing a single qualified candidate.
- Failing to submit any candidates for a job altogether.
These practices dramatically lower the chances of a successful placement and directly impact a staffing agency’s financial growth. Agencies that consistently fail to meet client expectations risk being viewed as unreliable partners.
The Impact of Poor Recruiting Practices
The numbers speak for themselves—when recruiters don’t submit sufficient candidates, the net number of contractors placed each month declines. This can then be directly tied to recruiter performance metrics.
Poor recruiting practices harm an agency by:
- Damaging the agency’s reputation with clients.
- Lowering monthly placement numbers and revenue.
- Increasing operational inefficiencies.
In today’s competitive labor market, agencies must focus on standing out from the competition by consistently delivering high-quality candidates. Tracking recruiter performance metrics helps agencies identify gaps in their processes and course-correct before issues arise.
Key Metrics for Evaluating Recruiter Performance
To improve recruiter performance, staffing firm leaders must set clear expectations and track recruiter performance metrics, including:
- New jobs assigned.
- Candidate quality.
- Number of qualified candidates submitted in a timely manner.
- Interview requests.
- Offers extended.
- Net new starts.
By tracking these recruiter performance metrics, staffing agency leaders gain actionable insights into the effectiveness of their teams and can identify bottlenecks in the recruiting lifecycle. For example, a low number of qualified submissions could indicate insufficient sourcing efforts or a lack of access to the right talent pool.
These leading indicators ensure recruiters stay on track and consistently contribute to monthly placement goals.
How to Increase Monthly Placements
Staffing agencies can improve their placement numbers by aligning people, processes, and technology. Here’s how:
- Train recruiters effectively: Ensure they understand sourcing techniques, candidate engagement, and the client’s specific requirements.
- Leverage technology: Use advanced applicant tracking systems (ATS) and sourcing tools to streamline processes and access a broader talent pool.
- Set clear expectations: Provide recruiters with measurable goals tied to recruiter performance metrics.
- Build strong pipelines: Maintain relationships with candidates even when no current opportunities exist, ensuring a ready-to-go talent pool.
By implementing these strategies and monitoring recruiter performance metrics, staffing firms can avoid the pitfalls of one-and-done recruiting and build sustainable success.
Questions Leadership Must Address Today
Leadership must evaluate whether their teams are set up for success by asking important questions that go beyond day-to-day operations. These include:
- Have we provided the tools and processes necessary for our team to succeed?
- Are we expecting more from our staff than they are capable of delivering?
- What steps can we take today to align strategy, processes, and technology with our financial goals?
Ready to elevate your team’s recruiting outcomes? Contact Recruiting Factors today to explore customized solutions that align your processes, empower your teams, and set your agency up for sustainable success.
Learn More
